Complaint

Complaint number
AfCFTA-000-158  
NTB Type
3.2. Conformity assessments  
Reported through
Web  
Complaint
South Africa, as a globally recognised wine-producing country and a committed member of the African Union, respectfully submits this complaint to the following African partner countries regarding the recognition and acceptance of South African wine certification and analysis, aligned with the European Union (EU) and United States (US) standards: Algeria, Botswana, Cameroon, Congo, Ivory Coast, Ethiopia, Gabon, Ghana, Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda, Somalia, and Zimbabwe.
The purpose of the complaint is to:
• Avoid duplication of analytical testing and audits
• Facilitate intra-African trade under the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA)
• Reduce cost and red tape for both exporters and importers
• Maintain product integrity and safety without undermining national regulatory oversight
• Land the principle, present illustrative figures – based on averages and a set of assumptions/scenarios – to underscore the impact and support our ASK.
South African wines exported globally already comply with the strict technical and regulatory requirements of:
• The European Union (EU Reg. No. 1308/2013, Reg. (EU) 2021/2117) – high-level summary attached hereto.
• The United States (Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, FDA).
• OIV (International Organisation of Vine and Wine) methods for testing and sampling.
These regimes comprehensively cover:
• Alcoholic strength, total/volatile acidity, pH, sugar content.
• Sulphur dioxide limits, contaminants (e.g. heavy metals, pesticides, ochratoxins).
• Microbiological stability, allergen declaration, and labelling compliance.
• Isotopic and authenticity testing, preventing fraud and adulteration.
• Nutritional information, now required under EU law (as of Dec 2023).

Testing is performed by SANAS-accredited laboratories (South African National Accreditation System), using OIV/OECD-certified methods. This effectively means that the results of all parameters tested by DOA are obtained from ISO 17025-accredited laboratories.
South African wines are exported to over 120 countries, including the European Union, the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, China, and Japan, without any non-conformance issues and on presentation of certificates issued by the National Department of Agriculture.
The East African Standards (EAS 138, 139, 140 & 104 – example attached) require the following:
• Analysis of alcohol content, acidity, sugars, SO₂, and pH (fully covered by South African reports and export certification process).
• Additional testing for heavy metals, methanol, esters, aldehydes, furfural, ash content, and dissolved solids.
• Mandatory Pre-Export Verification of Conformity (PVoC) and factory audits by inspection companies.

With regards to PVoC programmes, the South African wine suppliers are subject to the following process to obtain a Certificate of Conformity (COC) for every shipment, and the shipment (s) which are either prepared as a ROUTE A, ROUTE B, or ROUTE C.
ROUTE A – this route applies to exporters of ad-hoc consignments.
Documents proving conformity of goods to Kenyan Standards or approved International Standards are mandatory for every consignment, i.e. Test Reports, CE declaration (Conformité Européenne), Manufacturers specification, ISO Certificates.
Inspection and Container Sealing are mandatory for every consignment. For every shipment, exporters (producers or brand owners) must work through verification agencies, such as SGS (Société Générale de Surveillance - detail attached) or Bureau Veritas, and arrange additional tests and inspections. This is in addition to the standard tests provided by the Department of Agriculture (DFSQA, Sub-Directorate, Liquor Products).
Delays related to these tests vary significantly, ranging from two weeks to two months. The timeframe depends on the specific testing requirements and the availability of accredited laboratories capable of performing the necessary analyses:
• The National Department of Agriculture handles most tests.
• Less common tests may require outsourcing to other accredited laboratories.

ROUTE B - this route applies to frequent exporters and manufacturers and entails a registration process.
Upon proof of conformity, a Statement of Registration is issued, which will be valid for 1 year and will be submitted with every application for every consignment.
Physical inspection is conducted, and a CoC is issued if the goods comply, which effectively means they complete an annual registration of the products (including tests/analysis) and undergo quarterly inspections.
ROUTE C - this route applies only to manufacturers and effectively means the manufacturer is licensed with the inspection company.
It involves auditing of the factory where goods are manufactured.
Testing of goods is conducted at an accredited laboratory; a license is issued and is valid for 3 years; however, the exporter is still required to present test reports for the complete list of parameters on monitoring inspections. Physical inspection is conducted, and a CoC is issued if the goods comply. No wine exporters continue to license as the factory audit must be done by SGS and is in addition to globally recognised FSSC 22000 and IFS accreditation.
Costs/Fees (Noting that variations exists as in the case with Cameroon, but a generic approach has been compiled for illustrative purposes)
ROUTE A – the cost to cover all parameters amounts to about $385 per wine.
It is worth noting that these costs are only for analysis/testing, and do not include certification activity and associated costs as tabled below. These costs may also vary from country to country.
ROUTE B – around $225.00 - $600.00 for an annual registration fee per region (after all these wines have been registered on Route B, they must be tested again).
Allowing annual renewal, but only available once two Route A shipments have been successfully delivered. Thus, the analysis per wine ($385) is added to the registration fee ($1 222) on an annual basis. For example, if a South African wine producer exports 217 products, this effectively means that for the full spectrum of testing, the exporter pays $83 545 (217 x $385) for the analysis only. This equates to a total of $84,767 for the registration ($83,545 plus $1,222).
If the inspectors are required to “seal” the containers during loading, it incurs additional costs and is also subject to an extra charge.
Practical realities and feedback received (via exporters) also highlight the following:
• Although shipments can be sent via Route A or Route B, the latter becomes available only after two successful deliveries via Route A.
• Random inspections on Route B shipments incur an additional cost of $385 per selected wine. This can delay the order up to two weeks if the wines have not been tested on all required parameters.
• Smaller wineries conduct batch testing on entire bottled batches, reducing future testing expenses by reusing existing results for subsequent orders. Larger wineries test per bottling batch, necessitating fresh testing for each new production batch.
• Fewer SKUs result in a more cost-effective order.
• Unlike other regions, Zambia does not require a COC. However, lead and cadmium tests are mandatory for each SKU at $7.35 per SKU.
Manufacturing & Bottling Process in South Africa
Further consideration must be given to the guidelines for wine preparation, as well as the manufacturing and bottling process within the South African Wine industry. We are complying with the highest international standards and believe that our quality controls are world-class and can stand our ground in the global world. To this end, it is crucial to understand our modus operandi and to illustrate the process: -
Once a tank of wine is classified as bottle-ready, a tank sample is sent for analysis. The results will determine if compliant and SAWIS seals are issued accordingly. There is thus traceability which links the analysis of that tank to the number of bottles produced within that SAWIS seal range. At that point, it is highly unlikely that the producer is aware where the bottles will be sold. Be it South Africa, the US, the EU or any African country.
After bottling, control samples are tested for any deviations from the preliminary testing done. Upon the second batch of analysis done, a record is kept, obtaining export certificates if, at any point in the future, the bottle is deemed for export and not sold within South Africa for local consumption.
In addition, the export process requires an export certificate, which is the first step when the product is sold to an international customer. Without the export certificate, the exporter cannot perform any of the additional steps required to comply with the export procedures regulated and will be unable to provide a certificate of analysis for the import clearance process.
Submission for Exemption Based on Regulatory Equivalence
We propose that South African wines with existing EU- or US-compliant analysis and documentation be accepted by African member states, with waivers granted for:
• Additional analytical testing for esters, furfural, aldehydes, and solids.
• Factory audits and in-person inspections.
• PVoC or other third-party CoC issuance.
• Local re-labelling and redundant sampling upon entry.
This proposal is grounded in:
• Regulatory equivalence: South African wine regulation is based on EU and Codex standards.
• Risk-based approach: EU testing already covers all health and safety markers.
• Cost-benefit alignment: Removing duplicate tests reduces costs and improves competitiveness.
• AfCFTA principles: This proposal promotes regional value chains, harmonisation and trade facilitation.

• SADC MRA protocols: Recognition of conformity assessments within Africa is actively encouraged.

Safeguards and Quality Assurance
To support this proposal, South African exporters are willing to:
• Provide original Certificates of Analysis (CoA) issued by SANAS/OIV-compliant laboratories.
• Share audit reports and records of production facilities upon request.
• Cooperate in spot checks or post-clearance verification by local regulators.
• Implement QR-coded e-certificates for verification and traceability.
Precedent and Best Practice
Several regional trade arrangements and RECs (e.g. SADC, COMESA) already advocate for mutual recognition. The EU recognises South African wine under its Trade, Development and Cooperation Agreement (TDCA) and its Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA) framework.
We request that African importing states do the same in support of AfCFTA trade harmonisation and regional development.
Summary of Request
We respectfully request:
1. Acceptance of South African Certificates of Analysis and Conformity for wines meeting EU or US requirements.
2. Waiving of additional EAS-specific tests (esters, aldehydes, furfural, solids).
3. Suspension or waiver of mandatory factory audits and PVoC for wines of South African origin.
4. Recognition of SANAS-accredited laboratories and their test methods.

In summation, as a representative body, we take cognisance of the impact the policies impose on South African wine producers and wish to reduce the non-tariff barrier that limits the growth of trade in the African community and the consumer at a detriment.
We submit this in the spirit of African integration, trade facilitation, and mutual trust. We are confident that acceptance of South Africa’s well-established regulatory framework will strengthen intra-African wine trade, reduce costs for consumers, and support agricultural value chains across the continent.
We welcome the opportunity to engage further, make an oral presentation and provide supporting documentation.
 
Progress update note
 
Policy or regulatory NTB
No 
Location
EAC  
Reporting Country or Region
South Africa  
Date of incident
2026-10-20  
Status
New  
Product Description
South African wine produced from fresh grapes, including still wine (red, white and rosé), sparkling wine and fortified wine, exported in bottled and bulk formats, and classified under HS Heading 2204 – Wine of fresh grapes, including fortified wines; grape must, excluding that of heading 2009.
 
Total value
RAND46 882.50  
Date reported
2026-11-12  
Modified
2026-11-16 12:33  
Messages